Used 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia Price in the US
A used 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia in the US typically lists for $233,876–$292,424, with a median asking price of $270,035 across 4 active US dealer listings (as of 2026-10-17). The cheapest one listed right now is $184,995, a 2011 in Hamilton, NJ — below 95% of the market, so expect high mileage, a base trim or a branded title — check the vehicle history.
Browse by model year
typical price per yearCheapest 4 listed right now
ranked by price-
-
$250,1702011 Ferrari 458 Italia44,199 mi · West Hollywood, CA · Specialty Car CollectionView listing → -
-
$299,9952011 Ferrari 458 Italia25,859 mi · San Clemente, CA · European Exotic CenterView listing →
These are the bottom of the market, not the going rate — every one is priced below 95% of active listings. A typical used 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia asks $233,876–$292,424. Cars this far under: expect high mileage, a base trim or a branded title — check the vehicle history.
Deals on the map
2 pinnedFAQ
How much does a used 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia cost?
A used 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia in the US typically lists for $233,876 to $292,424, with a median asking price of $270,035 across 4 active US dealer listings. Nine in ten are priced between $194,771 and $298,481 (as of 2026-10-17, source: UnderMarket Cars).
Is $270,000 a good price for a used 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia?
That sits at about the market median ($270,035) for a used 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia. Under $233,876 puts you in the cheapest quarter of active US listings and under $194,771 in the cheapest 5%; above $298,481 is the priciest 5% (as of 2026-10-17).
What is the cheapest used 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia for sale right now?
$184,995 — a 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia in Hamilton, NJ, $85,040 under the median (as of 2026-10-17).
Are these MSRP or real asking prices?
Real asking prices from active US dealer listings, deduplicated by VIN — not manufacturer MSRP. They already reflect dealer discounts, and they exclude tax, title, registration and dealer fees.
How often are prices updated?
The listing data behind UnderMarket Cars is rebuilt from live US dealer inventory every few hours, and this used 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia page is regenerated from it when it is requested. The figures on this page are from 2026-10-17.
Explore more
Prices updated 2026-10-17. Data covers active dealer listings across the USA.